Southampton’s water supply has been given the green light for fluoridisation bringing much concern to local residents, the high court has ruled.
Residents of Southampton have shown a mixed opinion of the situation. 37 year old teaching assistant, Sonia Garcia, said: “I think the introduction of fluoride into our reservoirs is a bad idea. I don’t think it’s particularly necessary and the best way for children to look after their teeth is to clean them properly, rather than being force fed chemicals. It’s unnecessary and a waste of much needed money.”
However mother of two Helena Pesut, 42, commented: “I’m not concerned about the fluoride, as I don’t think it will really change anything. We already use fluoride in toothpaste and fizzy drinks, so I can’t understand why there is so much fuss over the situation.”
Back in February 2009, local resident Ms Milner challenged the decision of the South Central Strategic Health Authority (SCSHA), instructing local water supplier, Southern Water, to go ahead with fluoridation.
Two years on, the High Court ruled that the decision given by the SCSHA was lawful, rejecting accusations of a defective decision making process, set forth by Ms Milner.
Ms Milner attended court equipped with an application for judicial review, which has been supported by local Southampton anti-fluoride campaigns.
Bill Edmunds from a Southampton based anti-fluoride group called Hampshire Against Fluoride commented: “In fluoridated areas up to 40% of people exposed to fluoride at a young age develop fluorosis. White spots on the teeth in mild cases. Even in non fluoridated areas there are some who swallowing toothpaste or too many fluoride tablets also develop it. The SCSHA professor claims this enhances the teeth.”
Fluoride is a powerful poison and an active ingredient in many pesticides. An over ingestion of this can cause toxic symptoms and a tube of children’s fluoride toothpaste contains enough fluoride to kill an average weighing child under the age of 9.
Excessive exposure of the chemical has also been linked to arthritic symptoms and dental fluorosis. Indications suggest that fluoride can induce genetic damage, which can heighten the risk of cancer, particularly of the bladder.
On the other hand, the pros to fluoridising public water supplies have proven to reduce levels of tooth decay and prevent against cavities. Scientists say that fluoride is perfectly safe for human consumption if it is controlled below recommended levels.
The maximum dose of fluoride levels should not exceed 4mg/L for adults and 2mg/L for children. Anything exceeding these levels can potentially increase your vulnerability to certain diseases, particularly to the bones and joints. It is also seen that the positive effects of adding fluoride to a water supply can be achieved in other ways such as better dieting and better dental care.
In a media statement released by southern water referring to judicial appeal, southern water commented; “We note the outcome of the judicial review and continue to work closely with the strategic authority. We await the conclusion of a continuing legal challenge before any steps are taken towards adding fluoride to supplies.”
The company have confirmed there has currently been no fluoride added to the Southern Water supply area.
Related Articles:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2011/feb/11/flouride-tap-water-southampton
No comments:
Post a Comment